Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marg Escobar's avatar

I’m glad you wrote this piece. When you wrote your previous essay on the myth of the rescuer I thought of Ida and wondered about your opinion.

Expand full comment
Marg Escobar's avatar

I loved this movie. It impressed me for all the reasons you discussed here, but especially in the way the movie engaged it’s own culture and history. The priest was willing to keep the truth from her long after it was necessary for her safety. The aunt was a partisan, a hero in a lesser movie and also a Communist judge who sent who knows how many innocents by our standards to prison. How much did all that happened to her distort her as a person? The killer killed them in part to protect himself and his family from his own father’s attempts to help them. Fear, suffering, pain, hatred, bigotry but mostly fear corrupts and mutilates this ordinary person into a mass murderer and thief.

I remember the line from the mother in the movie Ordinary People about how lucky people are who were never tried by circumstances and never had to see what they are really like.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts