Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Caz Hart's avatar

Another clear sighted, impartial discussion.

The apartheid and genocide architecture has been in place for 75 years. The cumulation of those efforts are now coming to fruition, so it seems.

Expand full comment
DR Darke's avatar

::It does seem wrong to me, though, that the worst form of racist violence is defined so centrally by individual motivations when we know that racist violence works through structures, through complicity, and through the deniability afforded by our obsession with individual motivations.::

To really mangle a quote, "It is nearly impossible for people to see injustice when their well-being requires their denial of its existence."

I KNOW there's a quote where this is said a lot better than I just did! I just can't find it....

This rather perfectly ties into a YouTube series I'm watching, "COPAGANDA" by television critic Skip Intro (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udhDawfCLHo&list=PL2ac8vr2QyTdlWwd8OQIc1it6bAfMGPPC ). In the series he talks about how television has traditionally lionized the police as "a thin blue line" between decent people (or if we're being honest, Middle-Income White viewers!) and the hordes of (usually not-White and certainly not Middle-Income!) rabble that would burn everything to the ground. Whenever you see Bad Cops, they're always presented as "Bad", as in "outside the normal protective norm of the GOOD police!". Even shows that want to interrogate what being a "Good Cop" means tend to fall back on the tropes of the morally upright/incredibly driven Good Cop versus the corrupt/bigoted/lazy and incompetent Bad Cop who gives the force a bad name.

Contrast that with the cops who used military-grade hardware to remove Occupy Wall Street—a collection of unwashed, smelly, but peaceful protesters who set up a tent city in the Wall Street district as a way to shame Mayor Mike Bloomberg (an outright Billionaire and owner of a media empire as well as a financial, software and data company) and his Capitalist cronies; or the police in Uvalde, TX who courageously, and with no regard for their personal safety in the line of duty...just waited outside Robb Elementary School while eighteen-year old shooter Salvador Ramos proceeded to kill nineteen students and two teachers, while wounding seventeen others, before they finally bothered to go in and shoot him dead. This doesn't even cover the victims shot by police for Existing While Black.

How this ties into your piece, Noah, is that cop shows never see corruption, bigotry, laziness or incompetence as systemic—same as those who, when they throw around the term "genocide", tend to look for one person, or at most a group of persons, responsible rather than the system that made them possible. I think this is important because it shows how deep the desire to blame an individual over a system goes....

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts