Mary Peltola was just declared the winner in the Alaska Senate race; that means that the Democrats have flipped 9 seats, widening their Senate lead to 56-44. In the House, Democrats look like they will get around 260 seats. They won the popular vote nationwide by a stunning 14 points.
Donald Trump’s narrow victory in 2024 was treated almost uniformly by pundits, media outlets, corporations, tech, and even to some extent by Democrats as a sweeping mandate for whatever the fuck evil awfulness Trump shat out of his orange pie hole. In contrast, the reaction to the most sweeping electoral victory in 50 years has been what we might kindly call an abundance of caution.
The reactionary quisling shitheels at The Hill rushed to their keyboards to insist that the 260 seat Democratic majority was “fragile” and to caution that if Democrats dared to advance unnamed “culture war issues” (ie, any politics to the left of Mitt Romney) they would be washed away in 2028 when “Trump will not be on the ballot for Democrats to run against.”
—
Thanksgiving sale! it’s 40% off, $30/yr. If you value my writing and would like it to continue, please consider supporting me! and the cats!
Thanksgiving sale! it’s 40% off, $30/yr. If you value my writing and would like it to continue, please consider supporting me! and the cats!
—
From the other (and much less repulsive) end of the ideological spectrum, Michigan Senator Elect Abdul El-Sayed warned that “if all we do is kind of go back to what we’ve been doing in a moment where we’ve been given a mandate, I worry that we may not earn our mandate.”
El-Sayed is saying that Democrats need to be bold in pursuing righteous and needed change; The Hill is urging Democrats to be timid and genuflect to the fascists. These are very different approaches both substantively and morally. But I think it’s significant that both sides here believe that the Democratic majority is precarious—that the country has chosen Democrats briefly, but that if Democrats do not fight (per El-Sayed) or if they dare to fight (per The Hill) then they will face major reverses as soon as they hit the next election cycle.
The result of the perceived Democratic precarity is that public discussion has mostly assumed that Democrats have hit their high-water mark, and that the only way to really go is down. No one really thinks Democrats are going to have a 14-point win in 2028; no one thinks they will expand their margins significantly in House or Senate.
And it’s true that after a massive overperformance, you’d expect things to revert to the mean. But that raises the major question—can you expect Trump to revert to the mean? Will the fascist fool in the White House suddenly start to govern in a reasonable and sober manner? Or will he elevate rabid Nazi shitheads to lead the White House while his clown car cabinet grounds every plane in the country?
Trump Is Still Going To Be Trump
These aren’t trick questions. Trump is an evil narcissist and fascist who sucks down moral rot as enthusiastically as he falls asleep at cabinet meetings. He is not going to change—not least because there’s so little effort by media, elites, or the Republican party to get him to change. After an apocalyptic extinction level election which swept the GOP out of power in Texas and North Carolina, the entire conversation is about what Democrats must do or how Democrats must change. Should Trump end his grotesque and pointless tariff regime? Should he stop trying to turn the entirety of DC into a tacky Trump hotel? Should he stop his fascist goons from shooting Americans in the street? Should he admit he lost the war in Iran?
Hardly anyone even asks. It’s like Trump is some sort of bloated orange fascist national gaseous disaster. You don’t ask a fart to change its ways; you don’t discuss strategy with a mudslide. Trump is Trump, the embodiment of the white supremacy that is the true path of the US in the view of way too many. Obviously, they insist, he and his will regain their rightful place at the top as soon as their opponents make a single misstep.
But the thing is, Trump is president. Elections are largely a referendum on the incumbent, because most people assume that the president is in charge and is to blame when things go to shit. If Trump continues to do the sorts of things that made him incredibly unpopular in 2026, he is likely to be incredibly unpopular in 2028.
In fact, Trump’s popularity has trended steadily downward during his second term in fiftyplusone’s aggregator. From a high of 50.7% when he first entered office he has plunged into the mid-30s. If he manages to lose just half as many points in the next two years, he would be in the mid 20s in November 2028. That’s about the same as George W. Bush’s approval in 2008, when Democrats flipped eight seats in the senate and won 257 seats in the House.
It’s not like it’s impossible to see how Democrats could increase their numbers in Congress. In the House, Democrats in blue states like New York, Maryland, Virginia, and Wisconsin may draw new gerrymanders—both to boost Congressional numbers and to force Republicans to abandon their opposition to fair maps nationwide. In the Senate, Democrats have solid pickup opportunities in increasingly blue Wisconsin and North Carolina, and if people still hate Trump in 2028 like they did in 2026, they could also be able to flip seats in Alaska, Kansas, Iowa, Florida, South Carolina, and possibly even Utah, Indiana, and Louisiana. 58-62 seats seems plausible, given the wave we just had and the fact that Republicans seem committed to doing nothing different.
Democrats need to fight fascism first
The point here isn’t to defend Democrats from criticism. Democrats absolutely need to be pushed to fight for Democracy; if they don’t, Trump will continue to move ahead on a range of horrific genocides while destroying public capacity and gorging on corruption. We need investigations. We need procedural radicalism—like gerrymandering the fuck out of blue states. We need an aggressive legislative agenda to try to mitigate the devastating effects of Trump’s rule where we can get around the veto, and to prepare ourselves to hit the ground running when we have the Presidency.
But the focus on what Democrats need to do or not do, and the default assumption that Republican (ie, white male oligarch) rule is natural and right and inevitable has led many in the commentariat to undersell just how bleak a situation Republicans are in. After all, the absolute Republican midterm wipeout of 1974 was followed by the Republican presidential year brutalizing of 1976; the GOP midterm wipeous in 2006 was followed by the epic presidential year GOP incineration of 2008. Trump is not standing for reelection, but he won’t stop being President, and he won’t stop demanding loyalty from all other Republicans. Yes, Democrats have some power, but the main driver of 2026 was hatred of Trump. People are still going to hate him in 2028. Put the same main input in, you’re likely to get similar outcomes.
The truth is that what the Democrats do or don’t do will probably have little effect on the election results (save for gerrymandering in blue states, of course.) People vote on the President. So rather than getting lost in their heads about what they should and shouldn’t do and how to market themselves here and here and everywhere, Democrats could instead just focus on doing their fucking jobs.
Do oversight. Drag those fascist motherfuckers in front of committees and expose their crimes. Claw back funds from ICE. See if you can’t repeal the stupid tariffs. Come up with a framework for admitting defeat and withdrawing from Iran. Get funds to Ukraine. Protect abortion rights. Pass message bills on abortion and Congressional stock trading and Medicare expansion and force Trump to veto them. There’s a lot to do. When January rolls around, as El-Sayed urges, get to it. If Trump is Trump, and he is, 2028 will take care of itself.



I have to come to my substack subscriptions to read about trump without the sanewashing that the NYTimes and the Washington Post give him. He's a criminal doing criminal things, that the Six Supremes said are OK. I'm desperately waiting for the MSM to acknowledge "the fuck evil awfulness of Trump."
If you're not sure how evil trump, Rubio, and Miller et al are, you can read this opinion piece by Nicholas Kristof.
Trump ‘Disappeared’ Them in 2025. I Found Them, Locked Up and Famished.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/18/opinion/trump-deportation-south-sudan.html?unlocked_article_code=1.RlE.X7_M.vYiMIHonSwvM&smid=url-share
Honestly, Noah, I know you're trying to take a unique stance on this, but I can't see much of a difference between your argument and El Sayed‘s argument and that it refutes The Hill’s argument. The Dems absolutely must be furiously active in executing their promises to do something about both affordability AND accountability, no matter the defeats they will encounter in these 2 years of Trump and his gang obstructing them. I guess the difference between you and Abdul is that you're saying that even if they didn't do this they would be well positioned for the presidency in 2028. I can't disagree with that more, if this is what you think. To use an overused term, this is only a rental for the Dems. Doesn't matter what Trump does. He's peripheral in the equation. If voters see that Dems are unwilling to fight, then some enterprising, smarter-than-Trump bigot will outmaneuver the fading dolt and capture a goodly segment of the rapidly increasing number of people who feel disenfranchised (and this trajectory is not going to diminish in 2 years) because bigots will be bigots and pivot back to an easier cultural “other" populism. El Sayed is correct, if you say he's saying that this majority is precarious if the Dems don't show us exactly with legislature initiatives and investigations and prosecuting over these 2 years what they will repeat with someone without a veto pen at the helm. A large segment of this past round of voters will not just take Dems word on it that they will act only when they have executive leverage. These voters need to see action or they WILL turn to the dark side.
Income disparity. Don't underestimate it. This isn't about Trump. This is about income disparity and disenfranchisement.