Thanksgiving sale! it’s 40% off, $30/yr. If you value my writing and would like it to continue, please consider supporting me! and the cats!
Thanksgiving sale! it’s 40% off, $30/yr. If you value my writing and would like it to continue, please consider supporting me! and the cats!
—
This week Pete Buttigieg reminded us all that he’s a cringing centrist tool by coming out strongly against student loan debt relief. Asked for a policy on which he disagrees with past Democratic policy, Mayor Pete launched into the sort of Republican-curious white populist boilerplate we’ve come to expect from him.
One thing is, I think ... we really overtorqued on the student loan thing. As a party, I have a very hard time explaining to my relatives in Michigan who did not go to college why they should be paying for people who do. I believe there are ways to make sure that you come out of college debt-free. I believe college should be more affordable. I don’t believe in like a magic wand to fix that for everybody who borrowed money.
Many people have pointed out that Buttigieg’s inability to explain the value of debt relief to his family (or his donors) is a skills issue. You want the government to pay for roads, even if you don’t use those roads personally, because the economy benefits if goods and people can get to and from even remote locations in a safe and efficient way. You want the government to fund education even if you aren’t using that education because everyone benefits from an educated populace which includes doctors, nurses, engineers, computer scientists and, yes, historians who can explain to you why fascism is bad. We’re all connected, and investing in human flourishing helps humans flourish. Beggaring your neighbor out of uncontrolled jealousy and ignorance leads to—well, the current government of the United States, with its lost wars, grounded planes, concentration camps, and various genocides.
Buttigieg prides himself on being a communicator and he’s widely thought to be a smart guy. It’s not that hard to figure out that educating people is good and that creating a situation where only rich people can get educated without incurring crippling debt is bad. Why doesn’t he just say that? Is he a fool? A bounder? What the hell?
I think Buttigieg is kind of a fool and a bounder, and also in hock to big donors whose yachts and AI companions start to vibrate with rage at the words “debt relief.” But I also think that Buttigieg is saying ignorant bullshit for the reason that politicians in the US often say ignorant bullshit—which is to say, he’s influenced by bigotry, and in particular by what African-American literature professor Koritha Mitchell refers to as know-your-place aggression.
America hates its young
Mitchell defines know-your-place aggression as a negative backlash against the success of marginalized people. She is talking, specifically, about white backlash to Black achievement, as when Black businesspeople were lynched, or when the prosperous Black business district in Tulsa was razed by white goons in 1921, or when white slavers sold wifes and husbands away from each other because they hated the idea of Black people having stable relationships and homes.
In her book From Slave Cabins to the White House, though, Mitchell also notes that know-your-place aggression can target other marginalized people, like (for example) white women. And one common, but little discussed, target of know-your-place aggression is children and young people.
In general, we think of parents and adults as encouraging the success and flourishing of young people. Adults, in public discourse, are devoted to their children and sacrifice to put them through school and deliver them a better life. They want their kids to have more and to do better than they have done; they dream of their children having more and better choices.
Obviously, many parents do want their children to thrive. But also many parents, and many adults, react with resentment, rage, and even violence when their children make choices they disagree with or have options or opportunities they did not.
As one example, Josh Greenblatt, the head of the grossly ethnonationalist ADL, boasted earlier this month, “My children are Jews and they will create Jewish families in Jewish households. End of story. Non-negotiable.” This rejection of intermarriage was framed by some critics as an example of racism or bigotry against non-Jews. The main victim of this kind of demand for endogamy, though, is the children who are told they can only love people approved by their parents. Greenblatt is saying that he has patriarchal control over his children, and if they succeed on their own terms—by finding a spouse they love of a different background—he will respond with anger and perhaps more than anger. What that means is unclear, but some obvious possibilities are refusing to speak to them, disinheriting them, throwing them out of the house, or verbally abusing them.
This is again not uncommon. Parents frequently kick LGBT youth out of their homes, or make their homes so uncomfortable that LGBT youth feel they have to leave. Parents often bully their children out of choosing certain college majors with threats of withholding funds. Adults will call the police to beat and arrest young people who protest against genocide.
You could see this aggression as an attempt to assert ownership or authority; parents act as if they own their children (and adults act as if they own all young people), and they become angry and violent when young people assert their independence.
To assert independence, though, is also to set one’s own goals and to succeed at them. Or to put it another way, in all of these cases, young people are pursuing, and finding, success as they have defined it—they are embracing their own identities, finding life partners, discovering passionate intellectual interests, joining in community to stand up for their beliefs. And it is this success—not failure, but success—which prompts anger, backlash, and violence. When young people succeed, adults often see them as getting above themselves; they demand they be put back in their place. That’s how know-your-place aggression works.
College, young people, and know-your-place aggression
The debate about college costs and student loan debt is shot through with know-your-place aggression. Our current brutal college loan cul-de-sac was initiated (like so much that is evil in our country) by Ronald Reagan. First as Governor of California, then as President, Reagan waged war on public higher education. Nationally he reduced higher education funding by a brutal 25%.
Reagan’s rationale was steeped in know-your-place aggression. He argued that colleges in the era of ani-Vietnam protests were too liberal and that young people should not be subsidized to pursue their intellectual interests. In other words, he believed that young people were successfully developing their minds and their morals, and that that success was a presumption. Young people should subordinate themselves to their parent’s politics and their parent’s (economic) goals—they did not have the right to set their own priorities or pursue their own flourishing. Young people needed to know their place, and to make sure that they did, Reagan argued that the older generation should horde resources and starve educational institutions.
This ideology has prevailed. Funding for public schools has cratered. It’s why student debt has doubled in the past twenty years; it now exceeds debt from auto loans or credit cards. The skyrocketing costs of college—especially of public schools— and the restriction of public funding has made it less and less possible for those of modest means, or for those estranged from their parents—to get a higher education and pursue their dreams. It has also meant that students who come out of college with debt feel they have to make money, and cannot go into more rewarding, less well-paid jobs. (Trump has, not coincidentally, attempted to put draconian limits on public service loan forgiveness programs.)
The aggression directed towards young people overlaps nicely with aggression towards other marginalized groups. Women, who are blocked from many jobs that don’t require a college degree because of sexism, benefit more from college than men do, and are therefore more likely to attend (and rack up debt). Because of Black household wealth gaps, Black college graduates owe an average of $25,000 more than white college graduates. Marginalized people have higher incentives to go to college in order to overcome prejudice, and they have fewer resources to offset costs. Slashing college funding and then enforcing miserly student debt policies is a powerful way to keep young people, women, Black people, and other marginalized people in their place when they pursue and achieve success.
Buttigieg, know-your-place aggressor
Most discussions of student loan forgiveness resistance do not identify its roots in know-your-place aggression. For instance, the Atlantic’s Adam Serwer—a thoughtful writer who supports forgiveness—argued that the policy “is seen by a lot of people as a giveaway to rich kids” and that this “is a real politics problem supporters have to figure out how to deal with. It’s a different obstacle than the ones facing health care or infrastructure.”
As I’ve explained, I think this analysis is fundamentally flawed. Opposition to health care reform, infrastructure improvements, and any social spending in the US is all driven by a form of know-your-place aggression. Mainstream white Americans are historically, desperately afraid that public spending will benefit Black people and allow them to succeed. They do not want funds going to the “undeserving”—which is to say, they do not want them going to people they do not like who they fear may in fact be deserving, and therefore might be able to capitalize and build success if given a chance.
Similarly, the antipathy to student loan reform is framed as a dislike of rich students because the fear is that young people will be successful. It is not all that difficult to realize that rich families can generally pay for college; it is working class and middle-class families that struggle with massive student debt, not the wealthy. Assuring people that non-rich students would be the main beneficiaries of debt relief might help—but it is also unlikely to resonate with people who are using “rich students” as a metaphor for “undeserving presumptuous young people.”
After all, Buttigieg doesn’t say that the problem is rich students. He says that the problem is that people who didn’t go to college don’t want to pay for those who did—which is to say, his salt-of-the-earth relatives (or his salt-of-the-earth megadonors) think that young people who succeed by going to college need to be put in their place. They made bad choices and borrowed too much money in a system that decided to screw them for their dreams; they should therefore be punished for dreaming and for attempting and achieving success on their own terms.
The challenge, then, is much the same as making the case for health care or infrastructure. You argue from common values, point out that we want opportunities for all children, including yours and yours and Buttigiegs, and explain that destroying people’s dreams and educational opportunities leads to bad things like doctor and teacher shortages and a society that can’t recognize fascism when it puts its boot on our neck.
But also, recognizing know-your-place aggression means recognizing that objections to student loan relief are in fact wrong, immoral, and bad policy. That means that the goal is to defeat them, not to validate them and take them seriously as good faith positions. As we saw in the last election, while know-your-place aggression has a constituency, it is not always the most important thing for voters when you are losing a war, gas prices are up, and masked gestapo are shooting people in the street.
Student loan forgiveness and funding public colleges would improve everyone’s lives and no serious analyst thinks that Biden’s student loan forgiveness efforts hurt the Democratic nominee in 2024, or that people even remembered they’d happened. Democrats should pass good policy that encourages flourishing; they should not tolerate bigotry against anyone, and certainly not against the young people who powered them to a historic win in 2026. Buttigieg is a poor candidate for president for a lot of reasons, but his right wing populist pandering to know-your-place aggression and the grim politics of resentment would be disqualifying in itself.



From a purely economic standpoint- my student loan payments are going from roughly $200 a month to $800 a month- most of it interest. Everyone I know with student loans is in the same boat. That’s $600 a month I won’t be spending on anything else, and I’m having to reduce the amount I’m putting into retirement to as well. This will not be good for the economy overall.
This is such a helpful framing. I forget the author's name but a few years ago I saw someone call it "down, girl" language (when directed at women) - like you'd tell a dog to get off the couch. "Know-your-place" captures it nicely.