12 Comments
User's avatar
Dr. Jim Salvucci's avatar

I don’t disagree with anything in this piece, but there is an element that has been consistently deemphasized and even ignored by many analyses.

The Democratic establishment foisted Janet Mills on the electorate. She seems a decent governor and did stand up to Trump when others were cowering. Good for her. But she also is a standard-issue moderate and a septuagenarian when the electorate is looking for young leftists. I think the fact that Platner was the antidote to all that played a large role in progressives backing him and turning a blind eye to his myriad flaws that were literally tattooed on his chest.

That’s not an excuse for Platnerphilia, nor is it a counterpoint to your argument. I just want to point out the role of the Democratic establishment in creating this debacle. By constantly and perversely propping up the same-old, same-old, they’re making the ballot safe for future Platners.

Noah Berlatsky's avatar

I think the problem with Mills was not that she was old or somehow obviously unacceptable to the electorate; her early polling was quite good.

The problem was she didn’t seem to actually want to run. She ran an anemic campaign and then gave up.

There were other candidates who ran for governor instead and they should have gone with one of those. but fwiw, I wrote a whole post yesterday about how the establishment failed to actually try to stop platner!

Dr. Jim Salvucci's avatar

You are right. I should have referenced your post from yesterday. My apologies. In my defense, measures in internet years, yesterday was two months ago!

A Declining Democracy's avatar

Well said. Honestly, I think we just need to apply the "mensch" test to every candidate. Is s/he or is s/he not a mensch? And if the answer is no, we just need to walk away and stop making excuses for them. Platner failed the mensch test the minute that tattoo came to light.

Lucius's avatar

What's the mensch test?

A Declining Democracy's avatar

Mensch in Yiddish means "a good man", morally, ethically, honorably, and humbly. If our candidates fail on these measures, we shouldn't nominate them.

Lucius's avatar

Ah. I see.

We might have trouble finding enough of those to fill out one political party, much less an entire government. Maybe other countries have enough, but any faith I had in this country and it's populace left a long ass time ago.

A Declining Democracy's avatar

We have to take away the monetary incentives to weed out those who really don’t want to serve the public and are only doing it for the power and prestige.

Andy Reed's avatar

I disagree, Lucius. We need to ask ourselves - and the candidates and everyone who knows them -- what a mensch would do. Would he/she be someone you'd call to say "My mom just had to go to the emergency room and I'm out of state. Can you go to the hospital and check on her? She'll might need stuff from her house -- there's a key on the porch under the ..."

Or "I have to go out of town and have someone collect my snail mail; there'll be a few bills in there to pay. If I leave you a few signed checks will you send in the payments when they come?"

And know that your mom and your creditors will be taken care of, and nobody will ever hear about it because, as A Declining Democracy said, they do it "humbly" as well.

In other words, I would trust so-and-so completely and implicitly. That's why one of the questions I try to ask candidates is not "What is your position on X, Y, or Z," but "what are your values? What really matters to you?" And try to discern from people who know the candidate well, "How does s/he live her/his life?"

And ya know what? I have over 1,000 people in my contacts list, about 400 of whom are personal rather than business only -- and I'd trust all but about 5 of them implicitly and completely. Good people aren't that hard to find, if you live as a good person yourself and seek them out.