Delaware Senator Chris Van Hollen is challenging Chuck Schumer for the position of Senate Majority Leader. Schumer has led the Senate Democratic caucus since 2016, succeeding Nevada’s Harry Reid. His tenure has been controversial, and especially in Trump’s second term his popularity has taken a nosedive. His current approval is 23.6% and his disapproval is 63%—somehow significantly lower than Donald Trump’s.
Given these rock bottom numbers, it may not seem surprising that Schumer has drawn a challenger. And yet, many political scientists have expressed surprise. “I’m honestly at a bit of a loss on why there is so much focus on the senate leadership battle,” Darin Self said on bluesky, summing up a sentiment from many people who study Congress. “Caucus leaders mostly can’t create votes where there aren’t votes and function more as a reflection of the preferences of the caucus.”
Self and others are indisputably right about the Majority Leader position; Senate Democratic votes and Senate Democratic preferences are not necessarily going to change much whether Van Hollen or Chuck Schumer is in the chair.
Nonetheless, I think the challenge matters—first because the Majority Leader position isn’t just about Senate votes, and second simply because party actors have decided the party has decided the challenge matters. Democratic voters and many Democratic aligned organizations are frustrated with the priorities of their representatives and want to signal their desire for change. This is one way to do that.
—
Thanksgiving sale! it’s 40% off, $30/yr. If you value my writing and would like it to continue, please consider supporting me! and the cats!
—
Majority leader is a party leader
Again, many political scientists have pointed out that the Majority Leader is not primarily a public facing job. The leader’s main role is to negotiate intra-caucus politics. That often means they function as a sin-eater. As Georgia State political scientist Jeff Lazarus explains, if (as one example) there are not enough votes in the caucus for filibuster reform, it is the job of the leader to block filibuster reform votes so Senators don’t need to take a stand on a controversial topic. Then the leader ends up getting blamed and becomes less popular. That’s one reason (though only one) that Schumer’s numbers are abysmal.
There is, though, a kind of secondary public role for Majority Leader. They go on television and say things; they issue public statements; they are one voice of the party and are expected to articulate party priorities and stances.
Everyone agrees that Schumer is bad at being in front of a camera even by the low standards of most congressional leaders. House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries is not a brilliant speaker, but he is able to convey a certain urgency when necessary. Schumer in contrast has a unique gift for sounding both monotonous and fake; he comes across like an animatronic used car salesman.
That in itself wouldn’t be disqualifying, nor would the fact that Schumer clearly thinks he’s a great public speaker and rushes for cameras when by all rights he should hide from them. Speaking to the public isn’t his main thing. If he could do it that would be great. The fact that he can’t is embarrassing for everyone, but these things happen.
There are other parts of being a party (rather than a caucus) leader that do matter more, though. And Schumer is bad to terrible at those as well.
Specifically, as party leader, you are supposed to support the party. “The party” obviously, is a big thing, and doesn’t speak with one voice—which means you may sometimes need to support people whose policy vision does not perfectly accord with your own. You advance the fortunes of Democrats, ideally, and then you work out the best policy approach internally. You represent everyone, not just your faction.
The last couple of years have underlined Schumer’s inability to put party over faction. This is mostly linked (as I’ve written before) to Zionism. Schumer is a committed and enthusiastic Zionist, and he sees the Democratic party as inextricable from Zionism. In an infamous interview he told the NYT, “My job is to keep the left pro-Israel.”
Not only did Schumer say that, but he has acted on it, repeatedly putting loyalty to Zionism above loyalty to party. To repeat myself “Last year Schumer shockingly refused to say if he had voted for Zohran Mamdani, even though he was running against Eric Adams and Andrew Cuomo, two corrupt hacks with ugly connections to Trump himself.”
Schumer’s enthusiasm for Zionism, and his opposition to candidates who want to end aid to Israel while it’s committing massive human rights abuses, shaped his midterm strategy as well. He backed Governor Janet Mills in Maine, a Zionist who didn’t really want to run, launched a lackluster campaign, and thereby prevented other candidates from challenging the odious Graham Platner (who progressives like Bernie Sanders and, for that matter, Van Hollen, never should have backed; plenty of blame to go around in that race.)
Schumer also quietly supported Zionist Angie Craig in Minnesota, who then lost to progressive Peggy Flanagan. Angie Nixon, a progressive who scored a stunning primary upset and then narrowly lost in the general election in Florida, has said post-election that Schumer did not adequately back her.
And then there’s Congresswoman Haley Stevens. Schumer backed her in the Michigan Senate primary, where she ran an Islamophobic campaign against eventual nominee Abdul El-Sayed. She lost, disappeared—and then shockingly endorsed El-Sayed’s Republican opponent in the last days of the election. Schumer called Stevens’ actions “a despicable betrayal,” but if that’s the case, wasn’t his refusal to endorse Mamdani a similar betrayal? And why exactly does this keep happening?
It keeps happening in large part because Schumer is wedded to the politics of Zionism, and those politics are becoming less and less viable in the Democratic party. Most of Schumer’s Senate colleagues have voted to restrict aid to Israel. Candidates who run on ending Israeli aid do well in Democratic primaries, because that is where the base is—and they do fine in general elections, because Israel simply is not that popular with the American people right now, not least because it joined us in, and enthusiastically pushed, an illegal, massively unpopular, losing war in Iran.
Despite all of that, though, Schumer is using his position in leadership to run a rearguard action, trying to shore up his own Zionist and centrist faction at the expense of progressive candidates like Abduel El-Sayed and Peggy Flanagan—who not coincidentally have been among the first Senators to openly support Van Hollen. Even if it doesn’t matter that Schumer is bad on television, it does matter that he is using his control of resources and his standing in the party to push policies most Democrats reject, and to sandbag candidates who don’t share his (bad) ideological passions.
A Majority Leader who can’t endorse Democrats in key races, and who endorses backstabbing assholes like Haley Stevens, is a problem. A majority leader whose Islamophobia prevents him from standing in solidarity with Muslim Democratic colleagues targeted by the regime is a problem. That’s why many in the party (and at least some in the Senate) want to get rid of him.
The party decides (what to care about)
Zionism obviously isn’t the only issue that is driving interest in the leadership contest. Van Hollen courageously traveled to El Salvador to obtain proof of life of his illegally deported constituent Kilmar Abrego Garcia. That stands in sharp contrast to Schumer’s response to the administration’s efforts to deport his constituent Mahmoud Khalil, in which Schumer excoriated Khalil for his “antisemitic actions” (he did nothing antisemitic) before grudgingly suggesting that maybe Trump had overstepped. Van Hollen has said he wants to get rid of the filibuster; Schumer has been more reticent. Van Hollen supports Medicare for All; Schumer has not made a commitment to the policy.
And so forth. Schumer is a centrist; progressives have a ton of policy disagreements with him on immigration, on health care, on filibuster reform, on Israel. More, progressives, argue, their views are more popular in the party—Democrats favor filibuster reform, overwhelmingly oppose the Trump deportation policies Schumer could barely bring himself to condemn, and so on down the line. That’s part of why in polls Democrats prefer Van Hollen to Schumer in the leadership contest. It’s also presumably why Van Hollen was endorsed by the largest Nurses Union in the country, a major Machinist’s Union, Move On, Indivisible, and more.
Political scientists have (as I noted) more or less gently argued that these endorsements, and the attention to the leadership race in general, is misguided not because people are wrong about Schumer’s policy priorities, but because Schumer’s policy priorities don’t affect the Senate votes that much. Individual Senators are going to vote for the policies they prefer (which, thanks to the right-wing bias of the Senate, means they are going to vote for policies further to the right than most Democrats want.) Van Holen may be closer to the average Democratic voter than Schumer, but how much will that matter, really? Why not focus on a different fight that might be more productive?
Those aren’t bad questions. But I think the answer to why people pick a particular fight is sometimes that the fight is there and they’re ready to fight. The country just delivered a massive repudiation of the status quo; progressives up and down the ballot made substantial, impressive, and arguably unprecedented gains, winning primaries and elections in states like Michigan and Maine which were seen as bastions of centrism, as well as gaining a raft of House seats. Lots of Democrats are sick of the defensive crouch. They’re sick of being told that centrism is the only way forward. They’re sick of Zionism, of the corporate stranglehold on the party, of the politics of appeasement. They want to push Senators, and other leaders, to embrace the priorities of the party that elected them.
A Senate leadership battle isn’t maybe the best of all possible ways to have that conversation. But on the other hand, what would be better? Wait till the 2028 presidential election? Continue contesting primaries? Progressives and Democrats will do those things too. But if you’re looking for a way to assert your values and push the new majority towards better things right now, in a national context, this is it.
People have a sense of urgency for pretty obvious reasons. They also have a sense that our institutions—including the Senate, and including the Senate Majority Leader, have not served us all that well during a terrifying, brutal attack on our Constitution, our neighbors, and our lives. And so a lot of people are trying to change those institutions in a range of ways—from voting in the midterms to trying to get the Senate to be less of a reactionary clusterfuck.
Maybe (probably!) that effort is at least somewhat doomed to disappointment. But democracy is an exercise in being disappointed and then trying again. If calling your Senator can affect how Senator’s vote and behave, then it seems likely that a major mobilization demanding that the Senate reorder its priorities can also affect how Senator’s vote and what they prioritize. And if it puts a scare into Chuck Schumer, who is in many respects a disgraceful moral vacuum, so much the better.



Great piece on why we should challenge Schumer (D-Status Quo). Also, excellent job sneaking in “Self and others.”
"Schumer in contrast has a unique gift for sounding both monotonous and fake; he comes across like an animatronic used car salesman."
He sounds like an elderly father trying to give his grown son life advice, and Trump is his son....